YOU WERE IN LOVE WITH HER Lyrics

I saw you with her just the other day

In a picture that you posted

For her birthday

Saying 'happy birthday, my love'

I flash-backed to the night we fell apart

The screaming and fighting

Over the pieces of my broken self

Neither knowing how to help

I didn't know the pain would end

Didn't think I would feel my heart again

After you looked me in the eye

Fighting fire with your twisted lies

As if we never had that fight

You weren't the one to wreck my night

What were you thinking

What was running through your head

We could've talked but you ran away instead

Into the safety of her arms

I should've believed it from the start

You were in love with her

You were in love with her

I refused to believe I was just holding her place

Until you grew your spine and you could say

'I'm in love with you'

Straight to her face

I didn't know the pain would end

(How was I supposed to know?)

Didn't think I would feel my heart again

After you looked me in the eye

Fighting fire with your twisted lies

As if we never had that fight

You weren't the one to wreck my night

What were you thinking

What was running through your head

We could've talked but you ran away instead

Into the safety of her arms

I should've believed it from the start

You were in love with her

Was I not worth your time

Was I simply a pick up line

No backbone

So you crushed my soul

No regret

When I went from future to history

Why did I ever think that this was one big

Mystery

After you looked me in the eye

Fighting fire with your twisted lies

As if we never had that fight

You weren't the one to wreck my night

After you looked me in the eye

Fighting fire with your twisted lies

As if we never had that fight

You weren't the one to wreck my night

What were you thinking

What was running through your head

We could've talked but you ran away instead

Into the safety of her arms

I should've believed it from the start

That your heart was hers

And I was just enough

To be her placeholder

And you were

Always in love with her